Share

cover art for Deep South Dining |Elizabeth Heiskell - Come On Over

Deep South Dining

Deep South Dining |Elizabeth Heiskell - Come On Over

Elizabeth Heiskell rejoins Deep South Dining to talk about her latest cookbook, Come On Over!: Southern Delicious for Every Day & Every Occasion. Always ready to chat it up with her good friends Malcolm and Carol, this conversation is a celebration of all the things Elizabeth has done to stay at the top of the culinary ladder from her home in Oxford. Retelling how she and Carol first started together and what it took to put together book number four, Elizabeth also gifted us her delicious tomato pie recipe from the book before running to a book signing in Alabama. Later in the show Malcolm and Carol share what has been happening in their kitchens and the news that barbecue entrepreneur, Eddie Wright is the recipient of a Kingsford’s Preserve the Pit grant.


Show Links:

Virtual Discussion with Lemuria Books - Hosted by Malcolm White and Carol Puckett

Preserve The Pit - Eddie Wright


Excerpted from COME ON OVER! © 2021 by Elizabeth Heiskell. Reproduced by permission of Houghton Mifflin Harcourt. All rights reserved.


Tomato Pie

SERVES 6


I can’t talk tomato pie without telling you the mother of all tomato stories. When my husband, Luke, and I started our vegetable farm, we had a very clear plan: He would grow the vegetables and I would sell them. So Luke planted 10,000 tomato plants, and a few months later I got in our used prison van and headed to Memphis to sell those tomatoes. When I wasn’t out trying to sell the tomatoes, I was cooking up everything I could think of with tomatoes. When I wasn’t dreaming up tomato recipes, I was canning tomatoes. When I wasn’t canning tomatoes, I was drinking vodka . . . straight! (If you have never been faced with 4,000 pounds of tomatoes and no place to take them, then you don’t know real terror.) I was on my porch with a glass of vodka in my hand when Luke walked by and said, “Some people like to add ice and Bloody Mary mix to their vodka, Elizabeth.” And that, good people, is how my company Debutante Farmer Bloody Mary Mix was born.


In addition to Bloody Mary mix, during tomato season I make this pie almost daily. It comes together in a snap and is perfectly portable, and your guests and friends will always leave asking for the recipe.


  • 4 heirloom tomatoes, sliced (or any good ripe tomatoes will work; about 4 pounds)
  • Salt and pepper
  • 10 basil leaves, cut in chiffonade (see Chef Tip, page 79)
  • 1 cup mayonnaise
  • 1 cup shredded mozzarella cheese
  • 1 cup shredded parmesan cheese
  • 4 ounces goat cheese, crumbled (1/2 cup)
  • 1 (9-inch) pie crust, fully baked


1. Preheat the oven to 350°F.

2. Place the tomatoes in a colander in the sink and generously salt them. Let them drain for 15 minutes. Remove from the colander and pat dry with paper towels.

3. In a medium bowl, mix the mayonnaise, mozzarella, and parmesan.

4. Layer half the tomatoes and all the basil and goat cheese in the pie crust. Sprinkle with salt and pepper and then finish layering with the rest of the tomatoes. Top with the mayonnaise mixture and spread it evenly, completely covering the tomatoes.

5. Bake until lightly browned, about 20 minutes. Serve immediately.


More episodes

View all episodes

  • Deep South Dining | Easter Traditions

    49:25
    Topic: Dear friend of the show Tim Pierce returns to the show to discuss Easter Sunday food traditions as well as all things Easter in general as we rapidly approach Easter Weekend!Guest: Tim PierceHost(s): Malcolm White, Carol Palmer, and Java ChatmanEmail: food@mpbonline.org
  • Deep South Dining | Second Helpings

    36:01
    Topic: Java revisits some of Malcolm and Carol's tastiest conversations and grabs a second helping of food related subjects like tuna melts and cookbooks in this drive time episode.Host(s): Malcolm White, Carol Palmer, and Java ChatmanEmail: food@mpbonline.org
  • Deep South Dining | Mixed Bag Episode

    49:25
    Topic: Malcolm, Carol, and Java discuss a variety of food related subjects, from the Walter Museum of Art's food to tips on how to perfect your own comeback sauce, we look to have you covered in the world of southern cooking!Host(s): Malcolm White, Carol Palmer, and Java ChatmanEmail: food@mpbonline.org
  • Deep South Dining | Lena Pizza + Bagels

    49:47
    Topic: Dear friend of the show Tim Pierce returns to the show to discuss Easter Sunday food traditions as well as all things Easter in general as we rapidly approach Easter Weekend!Guest(s): Tim PierceHost(s): Malcolm White, Carol Palmer, and Java ChatmanEmail: food@mpbonline.org.
  • Deep South Dining | Jackson Restaurant Week

    50:12
    Topic: The city of Jackson is known, of course, as the City of Soul with rich history and culture and fantastic food. With nationally recognized restaurants and chefs, Jackson is front and center in the Mississippi culinary conversation. Joining us today to talk about that, the Jackson Restaurant Week, and other topics is Reshonda Perryman of Visit Jackson. Also with us today is one of our faves, Chef Enrika Williams to talk about what's going on in Jackson's culinary culture and in her world.Guest(s): Phil Stamps, Reshonda Perryman, Nick Wallace, and Enrika WilliamsHost(s): Malcolm White, Carol Palmer, and Java ChatmanEmail: food@mpbonline.org.
  • Deep South Dining | Toni Tipton-Martin

    55:07
    Toni Tipton-Martin is a renowned food and culinary historian, journalist, and author known for her work in celebrating African American culinary heritage. She joined Deep South Dining to share about her career in food and details on her latest book, Juke Joints, Jazz Clubs, and Juice: A Cocktail Recipe Book: Cocktails from Two Centuries of African American Cookbooks. Guest(s): Toni Tipton-MartinHost(s): Malcolm White, Carol Palmer, and Java ChatmanEmail: food@mpbonline.org.
  • Deep South Dining | Thank You, Please Come Again

    50:48
    Topic: Gas stations in the south are places where you can fuel your car, catch up with the neighborhood news, and get some of the best grub around... Mississippi native Kate Medley's new book, "Thank You, Please Come Again" takes a look at how these service stations help fuel the south in more ways than one. Today, we'll hear from Kate about her travels throughout the south picking up stories and photos from this service station, that conveince store and this quick-stop!Guest(s): Kate MedleyHost(s): Malcolm White, Carol Palmer, and Java ChatmanEmail: food@mpbonline.org.
  • Deep South Dining | The Big Apple Inn and Their Pig Ear Sandwich

    47:00
    Topic: When it comes to restaurants that have a history, community, and service behind them, and of course good food, we think about The Big Apple Inn in Jackson on Farish Street. It's Black History Month here in February, and today we are excited to have an old friend - owner and storyteller Geno Lee will join us to talk about the history of Farish Street, The Big Apple Inn, and of course to highlight Black History Month.Guest(s): Geno LeeHost(s): Malcolm White, Carol Palmer, and Java ChatmanEmail: food@mpbonline.org.
  • Deep South Dining | Sicily with Elaine Trigiani

    51:00
    Topic: Today we have our very special friend from Italy - Elaine Trigiani will join us after 20 years in Italy. She has designed experiences in the olive oil business, and she's going to tell us all about that. Guest(s): Elaine TrigianiHost(s): Malcolm White, Carol Palmer, and Java ChatmanEmail: food@mpbonline.org.